Version: 0.1
Date: 16 August 2026
Purpose: answer, for every normative provision in Standard v0.1, “Why is this in the Standard?”
Source IDs resolve to the bibliographic and applicability records in 01-source-register.md. Candidate IDs resolve to the full sixteen-stage records in 05-candidate-requirements-register.md. Open-issue IDs resolve to 08-open-issues-register.md.
1. Normative provisions#
| Standard provision | Problem and admission rationale | Principal external source basis | Candidate register basis | Normative status and evidence strength | Primary observability | Relevant open issues |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P-01 — Ex ante professional defensibility | Outcomes under uncertainty can retrospectively distort evaluation and turn conformity into a warranty. The principle fixes the object of evaluation at the report date. | GOV-01–03; RISK-01; DS-04–06; ASR-01. | CAT-01. | Principle; strong. | Report date and point-in-time basis; absence of outcome/decision warranty; use representations consistent with the authorised report. | OI-01, OI-34, OI-53. |
| P-02 — Proportionality with a professional floor | Uniform work is bureaucratic; unconstrained proportionality excuses superficial work. Explicit factors plus essential conditions reconcile use and integrity. | IA-01 Standard 4.2; RISK-01; DD-01; ASR-01; ETH-01; PRACT-01–04. | PROP-01. | Principle; strong. | Planning rationale linked to materiality, reversibility, complexity, uncertainty, reliance, threats, timing and use; essential-condition evidence remains present. | OI-03, OI-45–47. |
| REQ-01 — Conformity statements | Selective, partial or certification-like claims can produce pseudo-compliance and owner/provider advantage. A narrow engagement claim is needed if conformity is mentioned at all. | ETH-01; DRAFT-01; ASR-01–02. | SCOPE-01; CAT-01; CERT-01 rejected boundary. | Requirement; moderate to strong. | Documented all-requirements evaluation; exact report/marketing wording; no partial/provider/certification/assurance claim. | OI-01, OI-53. |
| REQ-02 — Qualification and acceptance | Too-late, inaccessible, conflicted, impossible or comfort-seeking engagements cannot be cured by later disclosure. | ASR-01–02; IA-01; ETH-01; PRACT-01–03; GOV-01–03. | QUAL-01. | Requirement; strong. | Dated acceptance/continuance record with decision, commitment point, remaining latitude, intended use, question feasibility, mandate/access, competence/resources and independence. | OI-02–04, OI-46. |
| REQ-03 — Decision question and mandate | Vague or sponsor-narrowed questions and inadequate authority can create an irrelevant favourable answer while implying decision approval. The decision, commitment, scope, roles and access must form one bounded unit. | IA-01 Standards 13.1–13.6; ASR-01–02; GOV-01–03; CONS-01; PRACT-02–03. | QUEST-01; MAND-01; AQT-01 rejected term. | Requirement; strong. | Controlled question/terms; role map; mandate/access rights and restrictions; scope-change record; report consistency; evidence of freedom to communicate adversely. | OI-05–09, OI-34. |
| REQ-04 — Competence and resources | Independent but unqualified judgment is not professionally defensible, and specialist delegation cannot cure ignorance or authorise reserved work. | IA-01 Standards 3.1, 4.2, 13.5; ASR-01; ASR-04; ETH-01; PRACT-01–04. | COMP-01. | Requirement; strong. | Competence/resource map to material question areas; roles and actual participation; specialist rationale; limits/referral; authoriser competence. | OI-10–11. |
| REQ-05 — Independence and conflicts | Legal separation can conceal self-interest, self-review, advocacy, familiarity, intimidation, future work and sponsor influence. Disclosure can be cosmetic. | ETH-01; IA-01 Standards 2.1–2.3; ASR-01; GOV-01–04; IA-02; ASR-07. | IND-01; SEP-01 informs but does not expand the requirement. | Requirement; strong core, moderate category-specific absolute guardrails. | Dated threat/interest/service/fee/prior-role assessment; safeguards and their operation; disclosures; decline/withdrawal; fee and direct-interest checks; unaltered adverse conclusion. | OI-12–15. |
| REQ-06 — Adequate basis and provenance | Source volume, sponsor assertions and analyst inference can simulate evidence. A non-assurance conclusion needs a quality/extent threshold matched to its strength. | IA-01 Standards 4.3, 14.1, 14.6; ASR-01; ASR-03; ASR-08; DD-02–03; PRACT-04; DS-08–09. | EVID-01. | Requirement; strong concepts, moderate threshold. | Material source/provenance trail; fact/claim/assumption/inference distinctions; quality/currency/consistency assessment; missing/conflicting information disposition; conclusion-support links. | OI-16–18. |
| REQ-07 — Material third-party reliance | A prestigious, available or contractually usable expert/report can be stale, conflicted, scoped for another purpose or methodologically unfit. Responsibility must remain with the practitioner. | ASR-04; ETH-02; IA-01; DD-02–03; ASR-01. | REL-01; REPERF-01 rejected. | Requirement; strong by analogy, moderate across source types. | Material-reliance inventory; purpose/scope/date/method/assumption/limitation assessment; relevant competence/capability/objectivity; added work; report disclosure. | OI-09, OI-19–21. |
| REQ-08 — Assumptions and uncertainty | Forecasts can present assumptions as facts, hide dependencies and use unsupported precision. Uncertainty must affect analysis and conclusion, not sit in a generic risk list. | RISK-01–02; PRACT-04; DD-02; ASR-01; DS-04–10. | UNC-01; CONF-01 rejected boundary. | Requirement; strong for transparency/restraint, moderate operational depth. | Material assumption/uncertainty record; source/rationale; plausibility/decision-effect testing; gaps/dependencies; report sensitivity/boundaries; support for any quantification. | OI-22–24, OI-52. |
| REQ-09 — Genuine independent challenge | A summary or friendly validation can be called a second opinion while retaining sponsor framing and evidence selection. Challenge must be substantive but method-neutral. | GOV-02–03; IA-01 Standard 4.3; DS-01–03, DS-07–08, DS-10–12; PRACT-01–04. | CHAL-01; TECHNIQUE-01 downgraded. | Requirement; strong outcome basis, moderate threshold. | Material framing/claim/assumption tests; independent source inquiry where relevant; plausible competing interpretations; counterevidence and disposition; reasoned stopping judgment. | OI-25–27, OI-31. |
| REQ-10 — Material dissent | Reasoned disagreement can be suppressed to create false consensus, while strategic immaterial dissent can obstruct release. A materiality and disposition rule is needed. | ASR-05–07; IA-01 Standard 13.1; GOV-02–03; DS-07, DS-12. | DISS-01; DISS-02 rejected. | Requirement; moderate. | Available escalation means; dissent issue/rationale/evidence/impact; consultation and disposition; output-authoriser decision; in-substance report disclosure or withholding/withdrawal. | OI-28–31. |
| REQ-11 — Conclusion boundaries and inability to conclude | Good work can become misleading through an overbroad favourable conclusion, buried fatal limits or commercial pressure to conclude despite missing essential conditions. | ASR-01–02; IA-01 Standard 15.1; ETH-01; DD-02–03; RISK-01; DS-04–06, DS-09. | CONC-01; NONC-01; CONF-01 rejected boundary. | Requirement; strong for boundary/disposition, moderate terminology. | Trace from question/basis to conclusion; point-in-time scope and material boundaries; prominence; remediation/reacceptance/limited or no-conclusion/withholding/withdrawal records; no assurance/approval language. | OI-16, OI-32–35, OI-46, OI-48–50, OI-53. |
| REQ-12 — Second-opinion report | Users cannot interpret a conclusion detached from the decision, work, assumptions, reliance, dissent, authoriser and authority boundary; unauthorised drafts can circulate. | IA-01 Standard 15.1; ASR-01–02; DD-02–03; PRACT-01–03; GOV-02–03; DRAFT-01. | REP-01; SCOPE-01. | Requirement; strong. | Dated controlled durable report; all enumerated content; status/version; whole-report clarity/balance; material-limitation prominence; conformity wording if used. | OI-01, OI-09, OI-33, OI-36, OI-44, OI-49, OI-53. |
| REQ-13 — Output authorisation and decision authority | A model, workflow, committee or ceremonial reviewer can diffuse professional responsibility; professional sign-off can be misused as client approval. | ASR-05–07; IA-01 Standard 15.1; GOV-01–05; IA-02; PRACT-01–03; AI-01–04. | AUTH-01; REV-01 downgraded. | Requirement; strong role basis, moderate generic role terminology. | Identifiable competent human; substantive review record; correction/withholding authority; dated release control; separate identification of decision authority; no approval/warranty representation. | OI-11, OI-36–37, OI-39, OI-51. |
| REQ-14 — Material delegated or technology-enabled analysis | Material automated or delegated contribution can hide provenance, error, bias and responsibility; a human signature can be uncritical. | AI-01–04; IA-01; ASR-04–08. | TECH-01; ARCH-01 rejected. | Conditional requirement; moderate. | Material-contribution assessment; role/input/provenance/assumption/limitation record; validation/corroboration; error correction/rejection; substantive human review; boundary disclosure. | OI-20, OI-38–40. |
| REQ-15 — Traceable documentation | Without a contemporaneous controlled trail, most requirements cannot be independently understood and hindsight can reconstruct the rationale. Audit-style identical reperformance and a prescribed case file are unnecessary. | IA-01 Standard 14.6; ASR-08; ASR-01, ASR-05–06; AI-02–04; DS-04; DD-02–03. | DOC-01; ARCH-01 rejected. | Requirement; strong by analogy. | Timely, coherent and versioned engagement record covering every listed decision and judgment; authorised report identification; retention/access basis under applicable obligations. | OI-17, OI-41–44. |
| REC-01 — Prior design and implementation interests | Prior proposal ownership and expected implementation revenue can make safeguards ineffective, but a universal firm-wide ban is not supported across all operating models. | ETH-01; IA-01–02; ASR-01; CONS-01. | SEP-01. | Recommendation; limited to moderate as a universal response. | Service/prior-work/network map; documented threat assessment; use of another/separate practitioner where chosen; governance and incentive evidence. | OI-12–14. |
| REC-02 — Independent pre-release review | Engagement leaders can be committed to their own analysis; separate review can help in heightened-risk cases, but a mandatory audit-style model is disproportionate. | ASR-05–08; IA-01; DS-01–09. | REV-01. | Recommendation; moderate in audit, limited direct category evidence. | Risk rationale; reviewer competence/independence; significant judgments reviewed; issues/dispositions; authoriser responsibility preserved. | OI-31, OI-37, OI-51. |
2. Non-normative content trace#
| Standard content | Basis | Why it remains non-normative |
|---|---|---|
| Guidance 7.1 — challenge methods | TECHNIQUE-01; DS-01, DS-10, DS-12; PRACT-04. | Different failure modes require different methods; completion of a named technique is gameable and no method is universally validated. |
| Guidance 7.2 — conclusion forms | CONC-01, NONC-01; ASR-01–02; IA-01. | A fixed taxonomy risks audit/assurance confusion and has not been user-tested across sectors. |
| Guidance 7.3 — internal/external practitioners | IND-01; IA-01–02; ETH-01. | Independence is functional and contextual; organisational examples cannot replace REQ-05. |
| Guidance 7.4 — point-in-time nature | CAT-01, QUAL-01; DS-04–06; PRACT-01–03. | Clarifies temporal interpretation; updating terms are contractual/professional and not validated as a universal duty. |
| Notes 1–4 | AQT-01, CONF-01, ARCH-01 and CERT-01 rejection records. | They prevent reintroduction of rejected constructs and do not establish new duties. |
3. Coverage check#
Every principle, requirement and recommendation in Standard v0.1 has:
- a concrete failure problem;
- at least one external primary or authoritative source family;
- a completed candidate-cycle record;
- a stated normative status and evidence strength;
- observable evidence of implementation;
- linked unresolved issues where the threshold or application remains uncertain.
No normative provision relies solely on Westbridge House practice. No rejected candidate reappears as a requirement under different wording.